You Actually Mattered (Acoustic Version) [feat. Mark Schmidt]

You look just so ridiculous right now
And you think you've got it all figured out
But you don't realize
It's no surprise

That you say you miss me
But you wouldn't hold my hand
And you say you love me
But you never proved it back then

When it actually mattered to me if you cared
When you actually mattered
And it actually mattered to me if you cared
When you actually mattered

Your love's just not contagious anymore
And I feel you just haven't seen what's in store
'Cause your open eyes only tell lies
In case you can't tell I've clearly moved on
Just leave me alone
I'm getting by
You've made me cry
But not this time

Now I'll say I miss you
And I'll wish that I held your hand
And I'll tell you I love you
And I should've proved it back then

When it actually mattered to me if you cared
When you actually mattered
(You actually matter to me)
And it actually mattered to me if you cared
When you actually mattered
(You actually matter to me)

Now you say you miss me
But you wouldn't hold my hand
And you say you love me
But you never proved it back then

When it actually mattered (Now I'll say I miss you and I)
To me if you cared (can't believe I wouldn't hold your hand)
When you actually mattered (And I'll tell you I love you and)
To me somewhere (I'm sorry that I never proved it back then)
When you actually mattered (I loved you)
Somewhere in my heart
Now the only love left has (Now whatever was stopping me has)
Fallen apart
When you actually mattered (I loved you)
Somewhere in my heart
Now the only love left (you actually matter)
Has fallen apart (you matter to me)

Now you say you miss me
But you wouldn't hold my hand
And you say you love me
But you never proved it back then

When it actually mattered to me if you cared
When you actually mattered
(You actually matter to me)
And it actually mattered to me if you cared
You actually matter
You actually matter to me