Lover's Torture

Sitting with you on a Thursday
Back when we were one and the same
I asked you if you'd ever play games with my heart
You seemed to think that it was crazy
To toss somebody's feelings around
But I could tell that you were someone who could start

Now here we are, apart
And I can feel your eyes on me from afar
And when I spin, you're smiling
As if you're saying "Let the games begin"

Oh, lover's torture
You're hitting me up again with that
Old lover's torture
I told ya, I told ya
Oh, lover's torture
Playing remember when with that
Old lover's torture
I told ya, I told ya you would

I can't help from looking over
To where you're sitting too close to her
You're touching knees, you're touching shoulders while you talk
And I can tell you're playing chicken
Cause with every laugh, you're looking at me, but
I know if I asked you, you would stop

So that's the game we're playing
All I've gotta do is tell you that you win
But as you'll soon discover, I'm far too stubborn
And I am not about to give in

Oh, lover's torture
You're hitting me up again with that
Old lover's torture
I told ya, I told ya
Oh, lover's torture
Playing remember when with that
Old lover's torture
I told ya, I told ya you would

I told ya, I told ya
I told ya, I told ya you would
I told ya, I told ya

Picked out a girl that you made sure I knew
I can find a guy who looks enough like you
When you see me with him, oh, you stop grinning
So I guess I'm winning, I guess I'm winning
Buying her a drink and you're spending all your money
I can laugh too hard at a joke that isn't funny
What I thought was over is just beginning
Now my head is spinning, oh, no one's winning

Oh, lover's torture
You're hitting me up again with that
Old lover's torture
I told ya
Oh, lover's torture
Playing remember when with that
Old lover's torture
I told ya, I told ya you would

I told ya, I told ya
I told ya, I told ya you would
I told ya, I told ya, ha