P.S.

Is it strange if I say I can still smell your car
On the shirt I grew out of
I only mention it 'cause it made me think
Of the nights we'd scream it all out the sunroof
Is it so weird if I fear for the day I pretend I never met you
Well I think it is, but I know I'll miss
The feeling today like the time before this
'Cause what happened to us

It wasn't fair
But we were there
But we were there
But we were there

I would've sold my soul for an alibi
I would've broken my bones for another try
Oh, I don't know what I'll do without you
I would've held onto you like a secret
'Cause you gave me something to believe in
Oh, I don't know what I'll do without you
Give me something to hold onto

Sometimes I feel like an empty balloon
In the middle of the street
I would ask you if you'd like to quit and
Meet at the places we used to meet
But to tell you the truth I'm just craving our youth
Being seventeen with brand new heartstrings
Every day I relapse, just looking back
When that song comes on, it's a cemetery
'Cause when I didn't know a thing about me

You were there
You were there
You were there
You were there

I would've sold my soul for an alibi
I would've broken my bones for another try
Oh, I don't know what I'll do without you
I would've held onto you like a secret
Give me something new to believe in
Oh, I don't know what I'll do without you
Give me something to hold onto

I'd love to catch up with you someday
Have another drink at the Garden Cafe
Do I need you now or do I mean the way
You were when you were just seventeen
Oh babe
I don't know
But I do know one thing
It's that I need another night in your car
In the drive-thru line
With the windows up, heaters on
But now I get so down whenever I hear that song