Coffee Shop

I met this girl in a coffee shop
I just had to say hello
She said her name was Olivia
As she picked up some sort of espresso
We sat and talked for about an hour
Before she had to leave
She said I have a doctor's appointment
But would you meet me back here at 3:00

And she's still on my mind
She stays with me all the time
And even though I was right there I never showed her any care
Big surprise I'm in a coffee shop again

I met this girl in a supermarket
She said her name was Caroline
But don't you ever sing her that Neil Diamond song
Cause she's heard it way too many times
She's got the smile of an angel
Like summer in the night
And she's got a fire that's undeniable
And lord she takes me for a ride

And Caroline is still on my mind
She stays with me all the time
And even though she was right there
I couldn't love her even though I cared
So I'm alone in this coffee shop again

And there she was just like a dream come true
She stole my heart away
She left me totally speechless
But now I've got some things to say.